Precision, Proportionality, and Pleadings: Costs Consequences in Illiquidx v Altana [2025] EWHC 1566 (Ch) In the latest instalment of the long-running dispute between Illiquidx Limited and Altana Wealth Limited & Ors, Mr Justice Rajah handed down a costs judgment that will resonate with commercial litigators and costs practitioners alike. The decision in Illiquidx Ltd v Altana Wealth Ltd & Ors [2025] EWHC 1566 (Ch) follows a liability judgment earlier this year, in which the court found that Altana and Brevent Advisory had misused Illiquidx’s confidential information and breached a non-disclosure agreement — but dismissed claims for copyright infringement and joint liability. The costs ruling is a masterclass in how the court balances success on liability with the conduct of the litigation and the proportionality of the costs incurred. The Starting Point: Success, But Not Without Fault Illiquidx (“IX”) was the overall winner on liability. Under CPR 44.2, the general rule is that the unsuccessful party pays the successful party’s costs. However, IX had failed on two discrete claims — copyright infringement and joint liability — and conceded that a deduction was appropriate. It proposed a 10% reduction. The defendants (“the Paying Parties”) argued for a far more substantial deduction — 61.5% — citing not only the failed claims but also the “expansive, imprecise and vague” way in which IX had pleaded and prosecuted its case. Should Costs Be Reserved Until Quantum? The Paying Parties urged the court to reserve costs until after the quantum trial, arguing that IX had exaggerated the value of its claim — pitching it at £10 million when, they said, it was worth less than £100,000. But the court was unmoved. “In complex litigation, requiring those who lose to pay costs as and when they lose is good policy… it encourages litigants to be professional in the conduct of litigation and to be selective of the points that they take.” — Rajah J at [8] The judge noted that no admissible Part 36 or open offer had been made that would justify reserving costs. Without such an offer, the court had no basis to delay its decision. The Real Issue: IX’s Conduct The heart of the judgment lies in the court’s critique of IX’s litigation conduct. From the outset, IX struggled — or refused — to define with clarity what confidential information had been misused. Its pleadings evolved through multiple iterations, from a “Big Idea” to a “Business Opportunity”, with shifting definitions and inconsistent detail. “There is no doubt in my mind that the costs have been significantly increased by the failure of IX to know clearly where it was going in this case.” — Rajah J at [22] The court found that IX’s approach had inflated costs at every stage: pleadings, disclosure, evidence, trial preparation, and correspondence. Disclosure alone involved over £1.1 million in costs and more than 13,000 documents — of which only 452 were referred to at trial. The Court’s View: A Substantial Discount, But Not a Departure from the Rule Despite these criticisms, the court declined to disapply the general rule that the loser pays the winner’s costs. IX had succeeded on a pleaded case — however obscurely pleaded — and the defendants’ defence had failed. “Quite apart from unnecessary costs, there is also a basic injustice in IX failing to identify its case and plead it with particularity and precision… The lack of clarity and precision… will, I am sure, have discouraged settlement.” — Rajah J at [23] The Order: 50% of Costs, with Interest and a Cautious Payment on Account In the end, the court ordered the Paying Parties to pay 50% of IX’s assessed costs on the standard basis, with interest at 2% above base rate, and a payment on account of 50% of that figure. This broad-brush approach reflected both the court’s disapproval of IX’s conduct and the need to avoid overcomplicating the assessment process. Key Takeaways for Practitioners Clarity in pleadings is not optional — it is fundamental to fair litigation and cost efficiency. Disclosure must be proportionate — vague claims can lead to sprawling, expensive exercises. Success on liability does not guarantee full recovery — conduct matters. Part 36 offers remain a powerful tool — their absence can limit a party’s ability to influence costs outcomes. Courts will act decisively — even in complex commercial cases, costs decisions will not be deferred without good reason. This judgment is a timely reminder that litigation strategy must be underpinned by clarity, discipline, and proportionality. For costs lawyers, it reinforces the importance of scrutinising not just outcomes, but how those outcomes are pursued. What are your thoughts? Why not join us on LinkedIn to continue the conversation.
Litigation Funding and the Costs Profession
Litigation Funding and the Costs Profession The Civil Justice Council’s final report on litigation funding, published this month, may not have made front-page news — but for those of us working in the costs industry, it marks a significant moment. It’s not a revolution, but a recalibration — a careful rebalancing of the relationship between funders, litigants, and the courts. The report follows the Supreme Court’s decision in R (on the application of PACCAR Inc and others) (Appellants) v Competition Appeal Tribunal and others (Respondents) [2023] UKSC 28, which held that many litigation funding agreements (LFAs) fall within the statutory definition of damages-based agreements (DBAs). That ruling introduced a degree of legal uncertainty — not just for funders, but for practitioners advising on the enforceability and structure of such agreements. The CJC’s report seeks to resolve that uncertainty and, in doing so, lays the groundwork for a more stable and transparent funding environment. Clarifying the Status of LFAs At the heart of the report is a clear recommendation: LFAs should be expressly excluded from the statutory definition of DBAs. This would require primary legislation, but the rationale is straightforward — to ensure that funding arrangements remain enforceable and accessible, particularly in complex or high-value litigation. For costs professionals, this proposed change offers welcome clarity. It removes a layer of ambiguity that has complicated advice to clients and funders alike. But it also prompts a broader question: if LFAs are to be treated as distinct from DBAs, what regulatory and procedural framework should govern them? The report begins to sketch an answer but much remains to be defined Understanding the Market We’re Working In The report is grounded in a detailed review of the litigation funding market. It notes that while the market remains relatively small in terms of volume, it is highly concentrated and plays a significant role in enabling access to justice — particularly in commercial disputes and collective actions. This context is important. As costs lawyers, we are often asked to assess the proportionality and reasonableness of costs in funded cases. Understanding how funders operate — how they assess risk, structure returns and influence litigation strategy — is increasingly essential to that task. Recoverability: A Continuing Limitation One area where the report is notably cautious is the question of recoverability. The CJC does not recommend that the costs of litigation funding become recoverable inter partes. While it acknowledges the arguments on both sides — particularly the role of funding in promoting access to justice — it ultimately maintains the status quo. This decision has practical implications. Costs lawyers must continue to advise that funding costs are not recoverable from the losing party, and that such costs must be borne by the claimant or deducted from damages. This remains a point of tension, especially in group litigation, where the economics of funding can be complex and the impact on claimants significant. Returns, Risk and the Question of Fairness The report also explores how funders structure their returns — typically as a percentage of damages or a multiple of the funding provided. While it stops short of recommending caps, it acknowledges concerns about fairness and transparency, particularly where funder returns significantly reduce the claimant’s share. This is an area where costs professionals may find themselves increasingly involved. As scrutiny of funding arrangements grows, we may be asked to advise not only on the enforceability of agreements, but on their fairness — especially where they are subject to court approval or challenge. Towards a Regulatory Framework Perhaps the most forward-looking aspect of the report is its call for a bespoke regulatory regime for litigation funders. The CJC suggests that oversight could be provided either by the Financial Conduct Authority or a new statutory body, with a focus on transparency, capital adequacy and fair dealing. This is a development costs professionals should monitor closely. Greater regulation may lead to more consistent disclosure of funding terms, which in turn could influence how we approach budgeting, costs management and settlement discussions. It may also affect how courts assess proportionality and reasonableness in funded cases. Group Litigation and Judicial Oversight The report also addresses the growing role of litigation funding in collective actions. It recommends clearer rules on how costs liabilities are shared among class members, and how funders’ returns are calculated and approved by the court. This is a welcome development. In recent years, the rise of group litigation has introduced new complexities into costs practice, particularly around apportionment and the fairness of funding arrangements. The CJC’s proposals suggest a more structured approach, which could help reduce disputes and improve predictability. It also signals a more active role for the judiciary in reviewing funding arrangements — particularly where they affect the distribution of damages. For costs lawyers, this may mean preparing submissions, disclosing funding terms and assisting the court in assessing whether the arrangements are fair and proportionate. A Role for the Costs Profession What emerges from the report is a picture of a funding landscape in transition — one that is becoming more central to litigation, more visible to the courts and more subject to scrutiny. For costs lawyers, this presents both challenges and opportunities. We will need to adapt our practices to reflect new regulatory expectations, to engage with funders more directly and to ensure that our advice remains aligned with evolving standards. But we also have an opportunity to shape the conversation — to contribute to consultations, to share insights from practice and to help build a funding system that supports both fairness and efficiency. The CJC’s report may not change everything overnight. But it does mark a shift — one that will unfold gradually, through legislation, regulation, and case law. As that process continues, the costs profession will have a key role to play — not just in responding to change, but in helping to define it. What are your thoughts? Why not join us on LinkedIn to continue the conversation.
