Lessons from Mazur v Charles Russell Speechlys LLP [2025] EWHC 2341 (KB)
Occasionally, a seemingly routine judgment sends a quiet tremor through firm governance. The High Court (King’s Bench Division) judgment in Mazur v Charles Russell Speechlys LLP [2025] EWHC 2341 (KB) is one such moment – a decision that every Managing Partner, COLP and department head should read carefully.
On its face, the case concerned a narrow point: whether employees without rights of audience or rights to conduct litigation had crossed the statutory boundary under the Legal Services Act 2007 (“LSA 2007”). But beneath that surface lies a sharp reminder of how easily “support work” can slip into “conducting litigation”, with potential criminal consequences and the very real prospect of SRA
The Judgment in Brief
Mr. Justice Sheldon examined how certain tasks had been delegated within the firm. The claimants argued that staff who were not authorised persons under the LSA 2007 had effectively been conducting litigation – not merely assisting those who were.
The Court reaffirmed that “conduct of litigation” is a reserved legal activity, tightly defined in Schedule 2 of the Act. It covers, amongst other things, issuing proceedings, filing documents, and corresponding with the court on behalf of clients. These are not administrative tasks. They carry professional judgment and legal responsibility – and must therefore be performed by an authorised person or under explicit authority.
In his reasoning, Mr. Justice Sheldon drew the crucial distinction:
- Supporting an authorised solicitor by drafting documents or managing correspondence under direction is permitted.
- Conducting litigation, even under supervision, is not – if the unqualified person exercises independent judgment or assumes control over the case’s progress.
This distinction turns on who holds the strategic responsibility. Supervision after the event does not convert an unauthorised act into a lawful one.
Governance Implications for Firms
The implications for law firm management are considerable. The LSA 2007 does not merely restrict certain activities – it criminalises their unauthorised performance. Sections 14 and 16 make both the individual and their employer potentially liable.
For larger firms, the risk is structural. Many departments, particularly in bulk litigation, debt recovery, and claimant personal injury, rely on paralegals or litigation executives to drive case progression. It is common for “file handlers” to run hundreds of matters with limited day-to-day input from qualified supervisors. Mazur effectively warns that such operational models need re-examination.
Supervision, to be defensible, must be demonstrable. Every experienced practitioner knows how quickly the line between oversight and autonomy can blur in a busy department. It is not enough to have a solicitor’s name on the file. There must be an auditable chain of supervision showing that strategic decisions, filings, and formal steps are directed and approved by an authorised person. Otherwise, firms risk exposure not only to SRA scrutiny but to criminal sanction under the Act.
A Call to Revisit Policies and Job Descriptions
One practical outcome from Mazur is the need to review how “fee-earner” roles are defined. Titles such as Litigation Executive or Case Handler may imply autonomy that conflicts with the statutory framework. Firms should make clear in job descriptions that such staff provide support rather than conduct litigation, and that all reserved activities are subject to solicitor sign-off.
Training should reinforce this distinction, particularly for newer staff – though even seasoned teams sometimes forget where “helping” ends and “conducting” begins. Too often, operational pressures blur the lines: a paralegal sends a court communication “for speed”; a team leader authorises a filing without solicitor review. Each act may appear minor, but collectively they build a picture of unauthorised conduct.
Firms should also revisit supervision policies. Do they specify what supervision looks like – frequency, format, and documentation? Are emails or file notes capturing supervisory direction? These details now carry real legal significance.
What Good Practice Looks Like Post Mazur
A prudent firm will treat Mazur as a governance opportunity rather than a compliance headache. Practical steps might include:
- Written Delegation Frameworks – clearly define which litigation tasks are reserved and require solicitor approval.
- File Audit Trails – ensure every reserved step has visible evidence of supervision or authorisation.
- Training and Induction – incorporate the LSA 2007 reserved activities regime into all staff induction programmes.
- COLP Oversight – conduct periodic sampling of files to confirm supervision is active, not merely nominal.
- Electronic Supervision Records – use case management systems to record authorisations and approvals by authorised persons.
By formalising these controls, firms can demonstrate proactive compliance if later questioned by the SRA or by the court.
The Wider Picture: Compliance, Costs, and Credibility
Mazur also intersects with the world of costs and indemnity. A firm found to have allowed unauthorised conduct may face challenges to its entitlement to costs, wasted costs orders, or professional indemnity cover implications. The reputational damage alone – particularly for firms operating at scale – can be severe.
Moreover, the case reinforces the SRA’s current regulatory mood: emphasis on culture, supervision, and demonstrable control. In an environment where the regulator is increasingly intolerant of blurred accountability, Mazur provides a timely reminder that compliance begins at the operational level, not in the policy manual.
Conclusion: An Opportunity for Self-Examination
The High Court did not set out to rewrite the law of legal services, but Mazur has done something more valuable – it has forced firms to ask uncomfortable questions about how work really gets done.
Every Managing Partner should now be able to answer, with evidence and confidence, one simple question: Who, in truth, conducts our litigation?
In an age where efficiency often drives delegation, Mazur reminds us that responsibility cannot be delegated, only exercised – and supervised – lawfully.
Thank you for reading this article.
If you found this article helpful, why not subscribe to our monthly Costs Law Newsletter? You’ll receive important updates, insights, and opinion in a concise, waffle-free email straight to your inbox.
Simply fill in the form below!
