Costs Management in the “Dieselgate” Litigation: A Reminder on Proportionality

  • Home
  • /
  • Costs Law
  • /
  • Costs Management in the “Dieselgate” Litigation: A Reminder on Proportionality

Costs Management in the “Dieselgate” Litigation: A Reminder on Proportionality

The High Court has once again delivered a clear message on costs in group actions: proportionality will be enforced with real bite. In Various Claimants v Mercedes-Benz Group AG & Ors [2025] EWHC 2307 (KB), budgets exceeding £55 million for the forthcoming Quantum Trial were cut back substantially by Mrs Justice Cockerill DBE, sitting with Senior Costs Judge Rowley.

Tranche 2 as the Benchmark

The judges made it plain that Tranche 2 provides the obvious comparator. That tranche involved a longer, more complex trial.

By contrast, Tranche 3, listed for eight weeks, should benefit from lessons learned and existing procedural structures. Costs should therefore be lower, not higher.

Attendance at Hearings

Particular concern was directed at hearing attendance. The claimants’ proposal of 32 fee earners across two CMCs, at a projected £3.3 million, was pared down to £850,000. Their £1.5 million estimate for the PTR was cut to £300,000.

The court’s stance was uncompromising: hearings do not require armies of solicitors, whether in person or online. The same discipline applied elsewhere. Claimants’ fortnightly meetings, costed at nearly £40,000 each, were reduced to £17,000.

The judges remarked that the process had become over-engineered, with excessive numbers of solicitors involved in preparation and follow-up. Non-lead firms also came under scrutiny. While clients remain free to instruct their own solicitors, the recoverable common costs of such firms will be tightly limited.

Much of their time will fall into solicitor-and-client costs, not common budgets recoverable between the parties. Steering committee work will similarly be judged against the yardstick of a single well-resourced firm

The Defendants’ Budgets

It is telling that the defendants’ collective budgets were higher still. Yet the court applied the same test of proportionality: whether the figures could be justified by reference to Tranche 2 or to the actual demands of Tranche 3.

Where they could not, reductions were imposed. Costs management, the judges stressed, is not a one-sided exercise.

Final Thoughts

The familiar problems — inflated attendance, duplication of effort, and elaborate processes — continue to drive disproportionate costs in group litigation. The court’s response was equally familiar: strict scrutiny and robust enforcement of proportionality.

For practitioners, the warning is clear. Be realistic in preparing budgets. Expect close examination. And remember that proportionality is not aspirational — it is the standard by which all costs will be judged, on both sides of the litigation.

Stay Informed

If you found this article helpful, why not subscribe to our monthly Costs Law Newsletter? You’ll receive important updates, insights, and opinion in a concise, waffle-free email straight to your inbox.

Simply fill in the form below!

[wpcode id="4941"]

Recent Posts

  • All Posts
  • BarnsChapel News
  • Costs Law
  • Legal News

Categories

Subscribe to our Newsletter!

Let’s Talk!

Have a question about Costs Law that we haven’t answered, or want to have a chat about what we do and how we do it?

Use the contact details below to get in touch, or fill in our contact form and we will get right back to you.

+44 (0) 1244 256865

office@barnschapel.co.uk

© 2025 BarnsChapel Ltd. All Rights Reserved