Precision, Proportionality, and Pleadings: Costs Consequences in Illiquidx v Altana [2025] EWHC 1566 (Ch)
In the latest instalment of the long-running dispute between Illiquidx Limited and Altana Wealth Limited & Ors, Mr Justice Rajah handed down a costs judgment that will resonate with commercial litigators and costs practitioners alike. The decision in Illiquidx Ltd v Altana Wealth Ltd & Ors [2025] EWHC 1566 (Ch) follows a liability judgment earlier this year, in which the court found that Altana and Brevent Advisory had misused Illiquidx’s confidential information and breached a non-disclosure agreement — but dismissed claims for copyright infringement and joint liability.
The costs ruling is a masterclass in how the court balances success on liability with the conduct of the litigation and the proportionality of the costs incurred.
The Starting Point: Success, But Not Without Fault
Illiquidx (“IX”) was the overall winner on liability. Under CPR 44.2, the general rule is that the unsuccessful party pays the successful party’s costs. However, IX had failed on two discrete claims — copyright infringement and joint liability — and conceded that a deduction was appropriate. It proposed a 10% reduction.
The defendants (“the Paying Parties”) argued for a far more substantial deduction — 61.5% — citing not only the failed claims but also the “expansive, imprecise and vague” way in which IX had pleaded and prosecuted its case.
Should Costs Be Reserved Until Quantum?
The Paying Parties urged the court to reserve costs until after the quantum trial, arguing that IX had exaggerated the value of its claim — pitching it at £10 million when, they said, it was worth less than £100,000. But the court was unmoved.
“In complex litigation, requiring those who lose to pay costs as and when they lose is good policy… it encourages litigants to be professional in the conduct of litigation and to be selective of the points that they take.” — Rajah J at [8]
The judge noted that no admissible Part 36 or open offer had been made that would justify reserving costs. Without such an offer, the court had no basis to delay its decision.
The Real Issue: IX’s Conduct
The heart of the judgment lies in the court’s critique of IX’s litigation conduct. From the outset, IX struggled — or refused — to define with clarity what confidential information had been misused. Its pleadings evolved through multiple iterations, from a “Big Idea” to a “Business Opportunity”, with shifting definitions and inconsistent detail.
“There is no doubt in my mind that the costs have been significantly increased by the failure of IX to know clearly where it was going in this case.” — Rajah J at [22]
The court found that IX’s approach had inflated costs at every stage: pleadings, disclosure, evidence, trial preparation, and correspondence. Disclosure alone involved over £1.1 million in costs and more than 13,000 documents — of which only 452 were referred to at trial.
The Court’s View: A Substantial Discount, But Not a Departure from the Rule
Despite these criticisms, the court declined to disapply the general rule that the loser pays the winner’s costs. IX had succeeded on a pleaded case — however obscurely pleaded — and the defendants’ defence had failed.
“Quite apart from unnecessary costs, there is also a basic injustice in IX failing to identify its case and plead it with particularity and precision… The lack of clarity and precision… will, I am sure, have discouraged settlement.” — Rajah J at [23]
The Order: 50% of Costs, with Interest and a Cautious Payment on Account
In the end, the court ordered the Paying Parties to pay 50% of IX’s assessed costs on the standard basis, with interest at 2% above base rate, and a payment on account of 50% of that figure.
This broad-brush approach reflected both the court’s disapproval of IX’s conduct and the need to avoid overcomplicating the assessment process.
Key Takeaways for Practitioners
- Clarity in pleadings is not optional — it is fundamental to fair litigation and cost efficiency.
- Disclosure must be proportionate — vague claims can lead to sprawling, expensive exercises.
- Success on liability does not guarantee full recovery — conduct matters.
- Part 36 offers remain a powerful tool — their absence can limit a party’s ability to influence costs outcomes.
- Courts will act decisively — even in complex commercial cases, costs decisions will not be deferred without good reason.
This judgment is a timely reminder that litigation strategy must be underpinned by clarity, discipline, and proportionality. For costs lawyers, it reinforces the importance of scrutinising not just outcomes, but how those outcomes are pursued.
What are your thoughts?
Why not join us on LinkedIn to continue the conversation.
