Two Judgments, One Question.

Two Judgments, One Question.

The question of whether a case should have been commenced within the Low Value Personal Injury Protocol (the “Portal”) is one that continues to generate litigation — and costs consequences.

It’s a decision that claimant solicitors must make early, often without the benefit of medical evidence or expert input, and based solely on client instructions and evolving symptoms.

Two recent decisions — Johnson v Choice Support and Ferguson v Royal Borough of Greenwich — offer contrasting outcomes on this very issue. Both cases examine whether it was reasonable for a solicitor to conclude that a matter should proceed outside the Portal. But they also go further, exploring the implications for costs when that decision is later challenged.

Case 1: Johnson v Choice Support [2025] EWHC 1020 (SCCO)

In Johnson, the claimant was a care worker injured while assisting a vulnerable adult. She developed foot drop following a herniated disc and had a complex medical history, including a prior discectomy and a diagnosis of MS. Her solicitors, acting without medical evidence at the outset, valued the claim above the EL/PL Protocol threshold and proceeded accordingly.

The court found that this decision was reasonable. The solicitors had:

  • Taken detailed instructions from a client who was open about her medical history,
  • Recorded contemporaneous notes of her worsening symptoms and concerns about long-term work capacity,
  • Written to the defendant’s insurers explaining their valuation.


Deputy Costs Judge Erwin-Jones emphasised that the solicitor’s decision must be judged based on what was known at the time — not with hindsight. The fact that the claim ultimately settled for £16,500 (within the Portal limit) did not render the initial valuation unreasonable:

“Her solicitors could not be said to have unreasonably valued the case in excess of the EL/PL Protocol limit.”

The court also considered whether the claim fell within the protocol exemption for harm caused by or to vulnerable adults (paragraph 4.3(8)). It concluded that the pushing incident — while foreseeable — did not amount to “harm, abuse or neglect” within the meaning of the exemption. The behaviour was not reckless or intentional, and the exemption did not apply.

Case 2: Ferguson v Royal Borough of Greenwich [2025] EWCC 30 (HHJ Brown)

In Johnson, the claimant was a care worker injured while assisting a vulnerable adult. She developed foot drop following a herniated disc and had a complex medical history, including a prior discectomy and a diagnosis of MS. Her solicitors, acting without medical evidence at the outset, valued the claim above the EL/PL Protocol threshold and proceeded accordingly.

The court found that this decision was reasonable. The solicitors had:

  • Taken detailed instructions from a client who was open about her medical history,
  • Recorded contemporaneous notes of her worsening symptoms and concerns about long-term work capacity,
  • Written to the defendant’s insurers explaining their valuation.

 

Deputy Costs Judge Erwin-Jones emphasised that the solicitor’s decision must be judged based on what was known at the time — not with hindsight. The fact that the claim ultimately settled for £16,500 (within the Portal limit) did not render the initial valuation unreasonable:

“Her solicitors could not be said to have unreasonably valued the case in excess of the EL/PL Protocol limit.”

The court also considered whether the claim fell within the protocol exemption for harm caused by or to vulnerable adults (paragraph 4.3(8)). It concluded that the pushing incident — while foreseeable — did not amount to “harm, abuse or neglect” within the meaning of the exemption. The behaviour was not reckless or intentional, and the exemption did not apply.

Key Points

These two cases — decided within days of each other — highlight the fine margins involved in early-stage valuation decisions. They also reinforce several important principles:

  1. Contemporaneous Evidence is Crucial
  2. In Johnson, the solicitor’s decision was upheld because it was supported by detailed attendance notes and correspondence. Courts will assess reasonableness based on what was known at the time — not with the benefit of hindsight.

  3. Protocol Exemptions Are Narrow
  4. The exemption for harm caused by vulnerable adults (or children) will not apply unless the conduct is abusive, reckless, or intentional. Foreseeable but benign behaviour — even if it results in injury — is unlikely to meet the threshold.

  5. Costs Consequences Can Be Severe
  6. In Ferguson, the solicitor’s unreasonable valuation led to a significant reduction in recoverable costs. While the appeal corrected the misapplication of CPR 45.24, the claimant was still limited to fixed costs under Section IIIA — a stark reminder of the financial risks involved.

  7. Judicial Discretion Must Be Understood and Preserved
  8. The appeal in Ferguson turned on the judge’s failure to recognise that CPR 45.24 is discretionary. Practitioners must be alert to the language of the rules and ensure that judges are properly directed — especially when costs arguments are raised late in proceedings.

Conclusion

So, should these have been Portal cases?

In Johnson, the answer was no. In Ferguson, it was yes. But in both cases, the solicitor’s reasoning, the documentation, and the court’s interpretation of the rules were decisive.

For claimant lawyers, the message is clear: early valuation decisions must be carefully recorded, clearly explained, and defensible based on the information available at the time. For defendants, the lesson is to raise Portal arguments early — and with precision.

In a fixed costs world, these decisions matter more than ever.

Recent Posts

  • All Posts
  • BarnsChapel News
  • Costs Law
  • Legal News

Categories

Subscribe to our Newsletter!

Let’s Talk!

Have a question about Costs Law that we haven’t answered, or want to have a chat about what we do and how we do it?

Use the contact details below to get in touch, or fill in our contact form and we will get right back to you.

+44 (0) 1244 256865

office@barnschapel.co.uk

© 2025 BarnsChapel Ltd. All Rights Reserved