Practice Update: High Court Ruling Clarifies Who Can Conduct Litigation
A recent High Court ruling has outlawed common practices used by many law firms, particularly in debt recovery.
In Mazur & Anor v Charles Russell Speechlys LLP [2025] EWHC 2341 (KB), Mr Justice Sheldon delivered a judgment that will require immediate review of staffing practices across affected firms.
What the Law Requires
The Legal Services Act 2007 (LSA) draws a red line: conducting litigation without proper authorisation is a criminal offence. Both the unauthorised employee and their employer can face criminal liability under sections 14 and 16.
The court however emphasised a crucial distinction that many firms have misunderstood:
- Supporting an authorised solicitor in conducting litigation (permitted)
- Conducting litigation under supervision by an authorised solicitor (prohibited for unauthorised persons)
For example: drafting a witness statement under specific direction constitutes support. Making tactical litigation decisions or signing court documents constitutes conduct of litigation.
The distinction highlights who exercises professional judgment and bears ultimate responsibility for litigation strategy.
The Case and Its Context
In this case, Mr Peter Middleton at Goldsmith Bowers Solicitors handled virtually every aspect of a debt recovery case despite lacking a practising certificate. He drafted pleadings, issued proceedings, conducted correspondence, and instructed counsel.
The Solicitors Regulation Authority (SRA) had initially suggested that section 21(3) of the LSA permitted this under supervision. That provision states that “regulated persons” include both “persons who are authorised by the body to carry on an activity which is a reserved legal activity” and “persons who are not so authorised but are employees of a person who is so authorised.”
The SRA’s flawed interpretation was that this brought employees within the authorisation framework. However, section 21(3) merely determines who falls within the SRA’s regulatory scope for disciplinary and conduct rules — it says nothing about granting authorisation to conduct litigation.
The Court's Analysis
Mr Justice Sheldon rejected the supervision defence:
“Mere employment by a person who is authorised to conduct litigation is not sufficient for the employee to conduct litigation themselves, even under supervision.”
Notably, the court deliberately avoided determining whether Middleton was actually conducting litigation or merely supporting it, stating this would be unfair given he wasn’t a party to the proceedings. The judgment establishes the legal framework but leaves factual applications for case-by-case determination.
Both the Law Society and SRA intervened, confirming that supervision cannot transform an unauthorised person into an authorised one. The SRA effectively abandoned its earlier interpretation.
Immediate Implications for Affected Firms
Firms in debt recovery and those using similar practices must urgently review:
- Current Cases: Audit who exercises professional judgment, makes tactical decisions, and signs court documents. Document the distinction between support and conduct functions.
- Ongoing Risk: Consider whether any proceedings may be vulnerable to challenge where the boundary may have been crossed.
- Process Changes: Redesign workflows to ensure clear separation between authorised conduct and unauthorised support.
The judgment specifically noted that using non-authorised staff to conduct litigation “is the norm in commercial debt recovery.” This norm now requires immediate scrutiny.
Regulatory Response
The SRA indicated it will “await this judgment before deciding what steps to take.” Whether this leads to new guidance or case-by-case enforcement through existing rules remains to be seen. However, firms cannot afford to wait for clarification given the existing legal framework.
Practical Challenges
The judgment provides legal principles but limited guidance on borderline cases. Questions remain about where precisely the line falls between permitted support and prohibited conduct in day-to-day practice.
Firms should focus on clear cases first: ensure only authorised persons sign court documents, make strategic decisions, and bear professional responsibility for litigation outcomes.
The Bottom Line
This ruling eliminates the assumption that supervision legitimises unauthorised conduct of litigation. Personal authorisation remains non-negotiable under the LSA.
For firms currently relying on supervised non-authorised staff to handle litigation functions, the message is clear: review, restructure, and ensure compliance with the statutory framework.
Finally, please keep in mind that the comfort of previous practice is not a safeguard against legal accountability.
Stay Informed
If you found this article helpful, why not subscribe to our monthly Costs Law Newsletter? You’ll receive important updates, insights, and opinion in a concise, waffle-free email straight to your inbox.
Simply fill in the form below!
