Success Fees, ATE Premiums, and Judicial Missteps

Success Fees, ATE Premiums, and Judicial Missteps: Duffield v Morrisons [2025] EWCC 35

In Duffield v WM Morrison Supermarkets Ltd [2025] EWCC 35, His Honour Judge Monty KC delivered a robust appellate judgment correcting what he described as a series of legal missteps by the lower court in a child personal injury claim.

The case is a timely reminder of the structured approach required when assessing deductions from damages in CFA-funded litigation involving minors.

Background: A Modest Claim, a Complex Costs Dispute

The claim arose from a 2022 accident in a supermarket, where the five-year-old claimant was injured. The case was funded by a CFA with a 100% success fee and an ATE insurance policy costing £675. The claim settled for £2,250, and the litigation friend sought to recover her reasonable expenses from damages, including£450 for the success fee and £675 for the ATE premium — the maximum 50% permitted under CPR 21.12(7).

Deputy District Judge Walton approved the settlement but allowed only £225 for the success fee and refused the ATE premium altogether. The litigation friend appealed.

The Appeal: A Written Judgment for Wider Guidance

HHJ Monty KC allowed the appeal, noting that the errors made by the lower court were “not uncommon” and warranted a written judgment to assist others dealing with similar issues.

The Success Fee: Contractual Basis Misunderstood

The lower court had reduced the success fee to 10% of the damages, citing Simmons v Castle — a case concerning the uplift in general damages post-Jackson reforms. HHJ Monty KC was unequivocal:

“It was not open to the judge to determine the amount of the deductible success fee by reference to a Simmons 10% uplift on damages. The Simmons uplift has nothing to do with the contractual recovery of a success fee.”

The correct approach, he held, was to assess whether the litigation friend had given informed consent to the success fee, as required by CPR 46.9(3). Since the evidence showed that she had, the full £450 was recoverable.

The ATE Premium: A Misapplication of West v Stockport

The lower court had refused the ATE premium on the basis that it was not reasonable to incur it at all, citing the low risk of adverse costs in a QOCS-protected claim. HHJ Monty KC disagreed:

“Having held, correctly, that there was a litigation risk in this case, it was not open for [the judge] to find that it was unreasonable for Ms Matuleviciute to have insured against that risk.”

He reiterated the principles from West v Stockport NHS Foundation Trust — that the reasonableness of ATE premiums must be assessed at a macro level, not on a case-by-case basis, and that proportionality is not the test.

Key Errors Identified

  1. Misapplying Simmons v Castle to quantify a contractual success fee.
  2. Failing to apply CPR 46.9(3) and the presumption of reasonableness where informed consent is given.
  3. Treating QOCS as eliminating all risk, ignoring the potential for adverse costs via Part 36 or disbursement liabilities.
  4. Assessing the ATE premium’s reasonableness in hindsight, rather than at the time it was incurred.

The Outcome

The appeal was allowed in full. The litigation friend was permitted to deduct both the £450 success fee and the £675 ATE premium — the full 50% of the damages permitted to be deducted under CPR 21.12.

Key Takeaways for Practitioners

  1. Success fees are contractual — they must be assessed on that basis, not by reference to damages.
  2. Informed consent is critical — where given, it triggers a presumption of reasonableness under CPR 46.9.
  3. ATE premiums are not to be second-guessed — their reasonableness is assessed at a macro level, not case-by-case.
  4. QOCS does not eliminate all risk — litigation always carries exposure, and insurance against that risk is legitimate.
  5. Courts must avoid reverse-engineering deductions — proportionality is not the test under CPR 21.12.

 

This judgment is essential reading for any practitioner advising litigation friends in CFA-funded child claims. It reinforces the importance of structured reasoning, fidelity to the CPR, and respect for the contractual basis of solicitor-client costs.

What are your thoughts?

Why not join us on LinkedIn to continue the conversation.

Recent Posts

  • All Posts
  • BarnsChapel News
  • Costs Law
  • Legal News

Categories

Subscribe to our Newsletter!

Let’s Talk!

Have a question about Costs Law that we haven’t answered, or want to have a chat about what we do and how we do it?

Use the contact details below to get in touch, or fill in our contact form and we will get right back to you.

+44 (0) 1244 256865

office@barnschapel.co.uk

© 2025 BarnsChapel Ltd. All Rights Reserved