When a Claim is Struck Out Against Multiple Defendants

  • Home
  • /
  • Costs Law
  • /
  • When a Claim is Struck Out Against Multiple Defendants

When a Claim is Struck Out Against Multiple Defendants

In MIL Collections Limited v My Shop 4 Ltd & Ors [2025] EWCC 38, District Judge Field was asked to resolve a complex costs issue following the strike-out of a claim brought against multiple defendants. The judgment provides valuable guidance on the application of fixed costs in multi-defendant litigation, particularly where some parties are represented and others are litigants in person.

The Background

The Claimant, MIL Collections Limited, had issued proceedings against thirteen defendants. However, the Particulars of Claim were found to be non-compliant, and the entire claim was struck out. At the time of the hearing, only the 12th and 13th defendants were legally represented; the remaining defendants (1st to 11th) were litigants in person.

The court was then tasked with determining:

  • Whether fixed costs applied.
  • Which table under Practice Direction 45 was relevant.
  • What stage of proceedings had been reached.
  • And how costs should be apportioned among multiple defendants, including those unrepresented.

Fixed Costs and the Applicable Table

The Claimant argued that fixed costs did not apply, or if they did, only the costs under Table 1 of PD 45 were relevant. The 12th and 13th defendants contended that Table 12 applied, specifically Table 12B, which governs claims concluded after issue but before trial.

District Judge Field agreed with the defendants. He interpreted “settles or discontinues” under Table 12B to include claims that are struck out — reasoning that the phrase should be read broadly to cover any conclusion of proceedings post-issue but pre-trial.

Determining the Procedural Stage

The judge then examined the chronology of the case to determine the applicable stage under Table 12B. He concluded that the claim had reached the stage “after allocation but before listing” — falling squarely within Table 12B(2).

This classification was critical, as it set the baseline for calculating the fixed costs entitlement.

Multiple Defendants and Cost Entitlement

The final issue was how to apportion costs among the thirteen defendants. The judge noted that, outside the fixed recoverable costs regime, each defendant in an unsuccessful claim is ordinarily entitled to its own costs. Since the rules governing fixed costs did not expressly disapply this principle, it remained applicable.

Accordingly, each defendant was entitled to an individual award.

Litigants in Person and Rule 45.4

For the unrepresented defendants (1st to 11th), the judge applied CPR 45.4, which limits costs recovery to two-thirds of the applicable fixed costs for the period during which a party is a litigant in person. All defendants were unrepresented at the time the claim was struck out, so the maximum recoverable amount was £1,720.67 each.

However, the judge made a distinction on assessment:

  • The 12th and 13th defendants were awarded the full capped amount of £1,720.67 each, as their legal representatives had already incurred costs on their behalf.
  • The 1st to 11th defendants were awarded 7 hours of time at £19 per hour — totalling £133 each.

 

The total costs payable by the Claimant amounted to £4,904.34.

Final Thoughts

This case is a masterclass in the practical application of the fixed costs regime. It demonstrates that:

  • Struck-out claims fall within the scope of fixed costs — even if not expressly mentioned.
  • Table 12B can apply to claims concluded by strike-out, not just settlement or discontinuance.
  • Each defendant in a multi-party claim may be entitled to costs, even under the fixed regime.
  • Litigants in person are not excluded from cost recovery — but their entitlement is capped and must be properly assessed.

 

For costs lawyers and litigators, MIL Collections v My Shop 4 Ltd & Ors is a reminder that the fixed costs framework is not static. Its interpretation continues to evolve — and careful attention to procedural detail can make a significant difference in outcome.

Stay Informed

If you found this article helpful, why not subscribe to our monthly Costs Law Newsletter? You’ll receive important updates, insights, and opinion in a concise, waffle-free email straight to your inbox.

Simply fill in the form below!

[wpcode id="4941"]

Recent Posts

  • All Posts
  • BarnsChapel News
  • Costs Law
  • Legal News

Categories

Subscribe to our Newsletter!

Let’s Talk!

Have a question about Costs Law that we haven’t answered, or want to have a chat about what we do and how we do it?

Use the contact details below to get in touch, or fill in our contact form and we will get right back to you.

+44 (0) 1244 256865

office@barnschapel.co.uk

© 2025 BarnsChapel Ltd. All Rights Reserved