Mid-Trial Costs Orders: A Rare but Firm Judicial Intervention

  • Home
  • /
  • Costs Law
  • /
  • Mid-Trial Costs Orders: A Rare but Firm Judicial Intervention

Can costs be awarded mid-proceedings?

In a highly unusual move, the High Court in Abbotsley Ltd & Vivien Inez Saunders v Pheasantland Ltd & Ors [2025] EWHC 2076 (KB) ordered costs mid-trial against the second claimant, Ms Saunders, due to conduct that wasted court time and disrupted proceedings. The judgment serves as a clear warning that the Court will not hesitate to impose financial consequences where litigation conduct crosses the line.

The Background

The case arose from a long-running dispute involving leasehold land and lodges at Abbotsley Country Homes. However, the focus of this judgment was not the underlying claims, but the conduct of Ms Saunders during the trial.

The Court detailed a series of disruptive incidents, including inappropriate courtroom behaviour, repeated interruptions in order for counsel to take instructions, and the late disclosure of dashcam footage. These incidents collectively wasted over 7.5 hours of court time, prompting the first defendant to seek a mid-trial costs order.

HHJ Walden-Smith also expressed concern that the litigation was being used as a tool to pressure the defendants, describing the behaviour as “out of the norm” and noting that such conduct was unlike anything she had encountered in her judicial or practising career. While the Court acknowledged the significant financial disparity between the parties, it made clear that its role was not to rebalance resources — but to address procedural fairness.

The Court’s Decision

HHJ Karen Walden-Smith accepted that the Court had jurisdiction to award costs at this stage under section 51 of the Senior Courts Act 1981 and CPR 44.2. She found that the delays were clearly attributable to Ms Saunders’ conduct and that it was appropriate to deal with those costs immediately, rather than waiting until final judgment.

The Court awarded £6,300 in wasted costs to the first defendant, calculated on the indemnity basis, and ordered payment within 14 days. The judge rejected arguments for a longer payment period or delayed appeal, noting that this was a discrete issue and should be dealt with promptly.

Notably, the Court accepted that a formal application was not necessary in this instance, as the issue had been raised and agreed informally between counsel and the judge. This suggests that where conduct issues are live and acknowledged, the Court may be willing to deal with costs summarily — a point worth bearing in mind for trial strategy.

Practical Implications

This judgment reinforces several key principles:

  • The Court’s discretion to award costs is not confined to the end of proceedings.
  • Where conduct causes identifiable delay and disruption, costs may be awarded mid-trial.
  • The Court will take a firm stance on behaviour that undermines the efficient administration of justice.
  • Financial inequality may be acknowledged, but it is not a basis for judicial rebalancing — costs orders will be grounded in conduct, not capacity.

Reflections for Practitioners

This case is a rare but important example of the Court exercising its powers to maintain control over proceedings and protect judicial time. For litigators, it underscores the need to manage client conduct carefully — particularly where a party is heavily involved in the litigation and inclined to test procedural boundaries.

The judgment also highlights the importance of courtroom discipline. Disruptive behaviour, even if not malicious, can have real consequences — both in terms of time and financial penalties. Counsel must be prepared to intervene early where a client’s conduct risks derailing proceedings.

The judge’s comments about the litigation being used to wear down the defendants — and her concern that every point, including bad ones, was being pursued in exhaustive detail — reflect a broader judicial discomfort with procedural overreach. This reinforces the need for practitioners to be alert to when litigation conduct crosses into abuse, and to be prepared to challenge it.

Ultimately, this case reminds us that costs are not just a postscript to litigation. They are a live issue throughout the trial process — and the Court is increasingly willing to act in real time to address procedural abuse.

Stay Informed

If you found this article helpful, why not subscribe to our monthly Costs Law Newsletter? You’ll receive important updates, insights, and opinion in a concise, waffle-free email straight to your inbox.

Simply fill in the form below!

[wpcode id="4941"]

Recent Posts

  • All Posts
  • BarnsChapel News
  • Costs Law
  • Legal News

Categories

Subscribe to our Newsletter!

Let’s Talk!

Have a question about Costs Law that we haven’t answered, or want to have a chat about what we do and how we do it?

Use the contact details below to get in touch, or fill in our contact form and we will get right back to you.

+44 (0) 1244 256865

office@barnschapel.co.uk

© 2025 BarnsChapel Ltd. All Rights Reserved