Judge Awards Hourly Rates Significantly in Excess of the Guideline Hourly Rates in Complex Commercial Litigation
In a recent decision, the Court of Appeal has affirmed the validity of retrospective Conditional Fee Agreements (CFAs) in the case of Singh & Ors v Ingram [2025] EWCA Civ 264. This ruling compels the paying party to honour the agreement, even if it was established post-commencement of the legal work.
The dispute centred on the legitimacy of a CFA agreed upon after the legal work had already begun. The paying party contended that the CFA was invalid due to purported regulatory breaches by the solicitors. However, the Court determined that the clients were fully informed and content with the agreement, and that the alleged breaches did not compromise its validity.
The Court was sceptical of the argument that alleged regulatory breaches by the receiving party’s solicitors provided grounds for the paying party to refuse payment. The clients were satisfied and understood the agreement. The Court also dismissed the traditional distinction between barristers and solicitors, affirming that solicitors bear just as much responsibility as counsel for the outcome of the litigation.
