Payment of Costs After a Split Trial: Judicial Discretion in Rogers v Wills
In Rogers v Wills [2025] EWHC 1711 (Ch), HHJ Matthews addressed a recurring but often under-analysed issue in civil litigation: whether a costs order should be made following a split trial where only liability has been determined.
The judgment offers a thoughtful and well-reasoned approach to the exercise of judicial discretion in awarding costs at an interim stage — and provides useful guidance for practitioners navigating similar procedural structures.
The Background
The Claimant succeeded on the issue of liability following a split trial. The question before the court was whether it was appropriate to make a costs order at that stage, or whether such an order should be deferred until the conclusion of the quantum phase.
HHJ Matthews undertook a detailed review of the relevant authorities and procedural guidance, including the recent decision in Illiquidx Ltd v Altana Wealth Ltd & Ors [2025] EWHC 1566 (Ch), which had addressed similar issues and was discussed in our July newsletter.
The Judgment
The judge concluded that a costs order was appropriate at the liability stage — but emphasised that this was an exercise of judicial discretion, not a rule of law. He ordered the Defendant to pay the Claimant’s costs on the standard basis, subject to detailed assessment if not agreed.
In addition, the Defendant was ordered to pay £75,685.50 on account of costs — a substantial interim payment reflecting the seriousness and complexity of the liability proceedings.
HHJ Matthews was careful to note that the decision to award costs at this stage was context-specific. It depended on the clarity of the liability outcome, the procedural posture of the case, and the interests of justice. The judgment reinforces that while split trials may delay final resolution, they do not necessarily delay cost consequences.
Key Takeaways for Practitioners
- Costs orders can be made after liability trials: There is no procedural bar to awarding costs at an interim stage, provided the court is satisfied that doing so is fair and proportionate.
- Judicial discretion is central: The decision to award costs post-liability is not automatic. It requires careful consideration of the case’s procedural history and the clarity of the outcome.
- Interim payments may be substantial: Where liability is determined decisively, the court may be willing to order a significant payment on account of costs — even before quantum is resolved.
- Recent case law is evolving: The judgment builds on Illiquidx v Altana Wealth, suggesting a growing judicial willingness to engage with costs issues earlier in the litigation lifecycle.
Final Thoughts
Rogers v Wills is a reminder that costs are not merely a postscript to litigation — they are an integral part of its structure. Where liability is resolved with clarity, the court may be willing to draw a line under that phase and award costs accordingly.
For litigators and costs lawyers, the case underscores the importance of being prepared to argue costs at every stage — and of understanding the discretionary framework that governs such decisions. As split trials become more common in complex litigation, so too will the need for strategic thinking around interim costs orders.
Stay Informed
If you found this article helpful, why not subscribe to our monthly Costs Law Newsletter? You’ll receive important updates, insights, and opinion in a concise, waffle-free email straight to your inbox.
Simply fill in the form below!
