Court and tribunal fees: updates from April 2025
The Supreme Court has unanimously ruled that solicitors must obtain explicit client agreement before deducting fees from settlement amounts, marking a significant shift in costs law practise. In Oakwood Solicitors Ltd v Menzies [2024] UKSC 34, the Court established that mere delivery of a statute bill and prior retainer agreements do not constitute “payment” for the purposes of the Solicitors Act 1974.
The Issue
The appeal centred on Section 70 of the Solicitors Act 1974 and what constitutes “payment”. The Supreme Court’s answer, delivered through Lord Hamblen’s leading judgement, emphasises that for solicitor and own client costs, payment requires client agreement to specific amounts, not just general authorisation for deductions from client account.
Case Background
The dispute originated from a personal injury claim where Mr Menzies received a £275,000 settlement. Under a conditional fee agreement (CFA), Oakwood Solicitors were entitled to deduct their basic charges, success fee, and ATE insurance premium, subject to a 25% cap of damages recovered. Following settlement, they issued a “Final Statute Bill” of £73,711.20 in July 2019, having already transferred £25,000 from client to office account in March 2019.
Procedural Journey
The procedural history illustrates the complexity of costs assessment proceedings:
- Following settlement of the claim, Oakwoods retained £73,711.20 from the claimant’s damages in settlement of their Final Statute Bill.
- The claimant sought an assessment of the solicitor’s costs pursuant to s.70 Solicitors Act 1974 (“the 1974 Act”) and lodged Part 8 proceedings at Sheffield District Registry.
- District Judge Batchelor transferred the matter to the SCCO for determination of the preliminary issue as to whether or not the request for assessment was statute barred.
- Costs Judge Rowley ruled that payment had occurred when the solicitors deducted the fees from damages and therefore, since that had occurred more than twelve months previously, the request for a 1974 Act assessment was statute barred.
- The claimant appealed to the High Court and Bourne J accepted the claimant’s position on the basis that there had been no settlement of account within the meaning of the 1974 Act which would have allowed the deduction to be treated as “payment”.
- The solicitors appealed to the Court of Appeal where Sir Geoffrey Vos MR allowed the appeal on the basis that the client’s agreement to the CFA rendered any formal agreement to the deduction unnecessary.
- The claimant appealed to the Supreme Court and won.
Supreme Court’s Analysis
The Court’s reasoning in the appeal focused on three key aspects:
- Ordinary Meaning: Lord Hamblen emphasised that whilst “payment” isn’t a term of art, its most natural meaning involves agreement to the amount charged. This is particularly relevant where the payment relates to solicitor and own client costs subject to assessment.
- Statutory Context: The Court found that Section 70’s focus on assessing whether costs are reasonably incurred and reasonable in amount makes it improbable that payment could occur before clients have an opportunity to consider their bills.
- Client Protection: The judgement emphasises that the statutory scheme exists primarily to protect clients’ interests, noting that the White Book commentary had long reflected this position.
Practical Implications for Costs Practice
The ruling has significant implications across several areas of costs practice:
Costs Budgeting Considerations
- Where cases are subject to costs management orders, firms must still obtain specific client agreement for bills even where costs fall within budget
- The relationship between budgeted costs and solicitor-own client costs requires careful explanation to clients
- Precedent H figures cannot be relied upon as automatic justification for solicitor-own client deductions
Assessment Procedure
- Detailed assessment proceedings may now see increased focus on evidence of client agreement
- The SCCO may need to develop new practices for checking compliance with the payment requirements
- Provisional assessment procedures may need adaptation to address payment agreement issues
CFA and DBAs
- Success fee calculations must be clearly explained and agreed
- The interaction between costs recovery and the 25% cap requires explicit client agreement
- Firms operating damages-based agreements should review their payment mechanisms
Client Account Considerations
The judgement has particular implications for client account operations:
- Timing of Transfers: Transfers from client to office account now clearly require prior client agreement to the specific bill
- Interim Bills: The status of interim statute bills and interim on account bills may need review
- Reconciliation Process: Client account reconciliation procedures should incorporate checks on payment agreements
Looking Forward
For law firms handling CFAs, particularly in personal injury claims, this ruling requires immediate review of billing practises. The emphasis on client agreement before payment may necessitate new systems for bill delivery, client communication, and payment processing, particularly where success fees and ATE premiums are involved.
The judgement returns to historical principles dating back to the 1843 Solicitors Act, affirming that genuine client agreement to specific bills remains central to the solicitor-client relationship, even in modern practise where costs budgeting and electronic billing are prevalent.
