Terminating the Solicitor/Client Retainer: A Costs Perspective from Evans v Acuity Law Ltd [2025] EWHC 1661 (SCCO)
In Evans v Acuity Law Ltd [2025] EWHC 1661 (SCCO), Costs Judge Nagalingam was asked to determine whether a solicitor’s decision to terminate a retainer just two days before a scheduled hearing was reasonable — and, crucially, whether that termination affected the solicitor’s entitlement to costs.
The case offers a timely and instructive reminder of the importance of clear communication, careful record-keeping, and managing client expectations — particularly when the solicitor/client relationship begins to break down.
The Background
The Claimant, Mr Evans, had instructed Acuity Law Ltd in relation to a contentious matter.
As the litigation progressed, the relationship between solicitor and client became strained. Two days before a key hearing, Acuity Law terminated the retainer, citing a breakdown in trust and communication.
Mr Evans challenged the reasonableness of that decision, arguing that the late termination amounted to a repudiatory breach of contract. He contended that the firm had failed to complete the “entire contract” and was therefore not entitled to recover its fees.
The Leagal Issue
At the heart of the dispute was the doctrine of entire contract — the principle that a solicitor is not entitled to payment unless the contract is fully performed, unless there is good reason for early termination.
The court had to consider whether Acuity Law’s decision to withdraw at such a late stage was justified, and whether it had preserved its right to claim costs.
The Judgement
Costs Judge Nagalingam found in favour of the solicitor. The termination, though close to the hearing date, was held to be reasonable in the circumstances. A key factor in the court’s reasoning was the solicitor’s meticulous documentation of advice given to the client — particularly in relation to unusual or non-standard costs.
The judgment noted that Mr Evans had either expressly or implicitly consented to those costs, and that the solicitor had taken care to ensure the client was informed throughout. This level of transparency and diligence weighed heavily in the court’s assessment of reasonableness.
Judge Nagalingam also acknowledged that while the timing of the termination was not ideal, it was not without justification. The solicitor had acted in response to a breakdown in the working relationship, and had done so in a manner that was consistent with professional obligations.
Implications for Practice
This decision reinforces several important principles for costs practitioners and litigators:
- Document Everything: The solicitor’s detailed file notes and written communications were instrumental in defending the claim. Where costs are unusual or potentially contentious, contemporaneous records are essential.
- Manage Expectations: Ensuring that clients understand the scope and nature of costs — and securing their consent — is not only good practice, but a protective measure in the event of future disputes.
- Termination Must Be Justified: While solicitors are entitled to terminate a retainer, doing so without good reason — or at a time that prejudices the client — may result in a loss of entitlement to fees. This case shows that even late-stage termination can be upheld if properly justified and documented.
- Entire Contract Doctrine Still Bites: The judgment is a reminder that the entire contract rule remains a live issue in solicitor/client disputes. Practitioners should ensure that their terms of engagement and conduct throughout the retainer anticipate and mitigate this risk.
Final Thoughts
Evans v Acuity Law Ltd is not just a case about timing — it’s a case about trust, transparency, and the professional discipline required to navigate difficult client relationships. It illustrates how the courts will look beyond the surface of a late-stage termination to examine the quality of the solicitor’s conduct throughout the retainer.
For practitioners, the message is clear: the best defence to a costs challenge is often found not in the retainer itself, but in the day-to-day habits of good record-keeping, clear advice, and client engagement. When those foundations are in place, even a difficult decision — like terminating a retainer days before a hearing — can be defended with confidence.
Stay Informed
If you found this article helpful, why not subscribe to our monthly Costs Law Newsletter? You’ll receive important updates, insights, and opinion in a concise, waffle-free email straight to your inbox.
Simply fill in the form below!
