DKH Retail Ltd & Ors v City Football Group Ltd [2024] EWHC 3231 (Ch)
The High Court’s recent pre-trial review judgment marks a pivotal shift in both trademark disputes and Alternative Dispute Resolution (ADR). By ordering mandatory mediation between Superdry and Manchester City FC, Mr Justice Miles provides crucial guidance on the October 2024 CPR reforms.
The judgment addresses when courts should mandate ADR, even where parties insist on judicial determination. As the court emphasised: “bringing the parties together through mediation can overcome an entrenched reluctance to negotiate, even where sincere.”
Three key principles emerge:
- Commercial complexity is not a barrier to mediation: The court found that even complex IP disputes benefit from mediation’s flexible solutions. This case involved branding on Manchester City’s kit featuring “Super” and “Dry” – potentially infringing Superdry’s trademark or representing Asahi Super “Dry” 0.0% lager sponsorship.
- ‘Need for judicial determination’ carries less weight post-CPR reforms: Parties often benefit from solutions beyond binary court outcomes. The court’s order to disclose the City Football Group-Asahi contract emphasised transparency in mediation.
Timing of mediation matters: Well-defined positions through pleadings and witness statements can enhance mediation prospects. A clear understanding of each party’s stance enables exploration of flexible solutions.
The success of the ordered mediation, confirmed in the judgment’s postscript, validates the court’s robust approach under the revised CPR framework:
- CPR 1.4’s express power to order ADR.
- CPR 3.1’s enhanced case management powers.
- CPR 29.2(1A)’s requirement to actively consider ordering ADR.
This judgment guides practitioners through the new ADR landscape in commercial disputes.
