Interim Statute Bills Under Scrutiny: Three Judgments, One Message

  • Home
  • /
  • Costs Law
  • /
  • Interim Statute Bills Under Scrutiny: Three Judgments, One Message

Interim Statute Bills Under Scrutiny: Three Judgments, One Message

Three recent decisions from the Senior Courts Costs Office — Mehta v Howard Kennedy LLP [2025] EWHC 1008 (SCCO), Topalsson GmbH v CMS Cameron McKenna Nabarro Olswang LLP [2025] EWHC 118 (SCCO), and Lansdowne Group Ltd v Weightmans LLP [2024] EWHC 1600 (SCCO) — have delivered a consistent and cautionary message to solicitors: if you want to render interim statute bills, your retainer must say so — clearly, expressly, and without ambiguity.

1. Mehta v Howard Kennedy LLP: Clarity Prevails

In Mehta, Costs Judge Whalan held that the 24 invoices delivered over an 11-month period were valid interim statute bills. The retainer explicitly stated that each bill was a final bill for the work done in the period and had the status of a statute bill unless otherwise stated.

“Paragraph 5 of the Terms of Business refers clearly to the fact that ‘each bill issued to you is a final bill covering the total charge for the work carried out within the stated period’.” — Whalan J

The court rejected the argument that references to “value” or “importance” charges undermined finality, noting that such provisions were not triggered in this case and were not incorporated into the contract.

The court also confirmed that the retainer fell under the ss.69–71 regime of the Solicitors Act 1974, not the Contentious Business Agreement regime under ss.59–63. As a result, the client could not invoke the “fair and reasonable” test under s.61.

2. Topalsson v CMS: Absence of Finality Proved Fatal

In contrast, Topalsson saw Senior Costs Judge Gordon-Saker conclude that 26 of the 27 invoices rendered were not interim statute bills. The retainer lacked any express provision stating that monthly bills would be final for the period they covered.

“Although it was provided that ‘each bill will state the period which it covers’, it was not stated that the bills would be final for that period. ‘Covered’ does not mean ‘sealed’.” — Gordon-Saker J

The court found that the bills formed a Chamberlain bill — a series of on-account bills culminating in a single final statute bill. Because the final bill was delivered within 12 months of proceedings, the client was entitled to assessment under s.70(2) without needing to show special circumstances.

The court also accepted that costs estimates which significantly increased over time constituted special circumstances justifying assessment of earlier bills, had that been necessary.

3. Lansdowne v Weightmans: Ambiguity Undermines Billing Rights

In Lansdowne, Costs Judge Nagalingam found that the solicitor did not have an express contractual right to render interim statute bills. The retainer documents were ambiguous, and the court resolved that ambiguity in favour of the client.

“The contract in this matter does not expressly provide for the raising of interim statute bills, and if it does then it is in ambiguous terms at best.” — Nagalingam J

The judge was particularly critical of overlapping billing periods, inconsistent invoice labelling, and the absence of clear language stating that bills were final for the period covered. The court also rejected the solicitor’s attempt to retrospectively “correct” overlapping bills by conceding time as de minimis.

The result: the court ordered the delivery of a compliant bill under CPR 46.10, and the client retained the right to seek assessment.

Key Takeaways for Practitioners

  1. Express language is essential — Retainers must clearly state that interim bills are final for the period covered and have the status of statute bills.
  2. Ambiguity will be resolved against the solicitor — Courts will not infer rights to render statute bills from vague or inconsistent drafting.
  3. Overlapping billing periods are fatal — Even minor overlaps can break the chain and undermine the status of earlier bills.
  4. Chamberlain bills remain viable — Where no interim statute bills exist, a final bill may incorporate earlier on-account bills.
  5. Client protections matter — Courts are increasingly alert to the practical consequences of billing practices that may prejudice clients’ rights under the Solicitors Act.

 

These three judgments reinforce a simple but powerful principle: if you want to rely on interim statute bills, draft your retainer accordingly — and get it right the first time.

What are your thoughts?

Why not join us on LinkedIn to be part of the conversation.

Recent Posts

  • All Posts
  • BarnsChapel News
  • Costs Law
  • Legal News

Categories

Subscribe to our Newsletter!

Let’s Talk!

Have a question about Costs Law that we haven’t answered, or want to have a chat about what we do and how we do it?

Use the contact details below to get in touch, or fill in our contact form and we will get right back to you.

+44 (0) 1244 256865

office@barnschapel.co.uk

© 2025 BarnsChapel Ltd. All Rights Reserved