When “Broad Brush” Becomes a Blunt Instrument: A High Court Reminder on Points of Dispute
In the world of costs litigation, precision isn’t just preferred — it’s required. A recent High Court decision in Ward v Rai [2025] EWHC 1681 (KB) has brought this into sharp focus, offering a timely reminder that Points of Dispute must be properly particularised — or risk being struck out entirely.
This case, heard before Mrs Justice Hill with Costs Judge Leonard sitting as assessor, concerned a familiar but critical issue: the adequacy of Points of Dispute served in response to a claimant’s bill of costs. The defendant had filed Points that, while lengthy, were ultimately too vague to meet the standards set by PD47 8.2(b). When they attempted to serve a more detailed annotated schedule just two working days before the detailed assessment hearing, the claimant objected — and eventually, on appeal, succeeded.
The Background
The defendant’s original Points of Dispute included generalised criticisms — for example, that time claimed was “excessive” or “duplicative” — but failed to identify specific bill items or provide clear grounds for the objections. The claimant, in their Replies, challenged the adequacy of these Points and applied to have them struck out.
The defendant’s response? A detailed annotated schedule, served at the eleventh hour, which for the first time identified the specific entries in dispute and categorised the objections. But by then, the damage was done.
The Costs Judge initially allowed the late material, but the High Court took a different view. On appeal, Mrs Justice Hill found that the judge had erred in principle by permitting the defendant to rely on the schedule, and that doing so undermined the overriding objective of dealing with cases justly and at proportionate cost.
What the Court Said
The judgment is rich with practical guidance. Here are some of the main points to consider:
- PD47 8.2(b) is not optional: Points of Dispute must state “concisely the nature and grounds of the dispute.” Generalised assertions — even if lengthy — are not enough. The court reaffirmed that a declaration that something is “excessive” does not, in itself, constitute a valid objection.
- Timing matters: The defendant had been on notice of the claimant’s objections for over seven months. Their failure to remedy the deficiencies until two days before the hearing was, in the court’s view, “even more egregious” than in previous cases such as Ainsworth v Stewarts Law LLP and Celtic Bioenergy Ltd v Knowles Ltd.
- The risk of ambush: While the defendant argued that the claimant had been aware a schedule was forthcoming, the court found that the late service still amounted to an ambush. The annotated schedule introduced new, specific objections that the claimant could not reasonably have anticipated from the original Points.
- The cost of delay: The late service of the schedule caused the detailed assessment to overrun into a third day — something the court found could have been avoided had the Points been properly drafted from the outset.
Practical Lessons for Costs Practitioners
This case is a cautionary tale for anyone involved in drafting Points of Dispute. Here are three practical takeaways:
- Front-load your work: Invest the time to draft fully particularised Points at the outset. If you’re not ready to challenge a specific item, don’t include a placeholder — wait until you can articulate a clear, rule-compliant objection.
- Avoid the temptation to “fix it later”: Courts are increasingly unwilling to tolerate late amendments, especially where they introduce new arguments or cause delay. The discretion under PD47 13.10(2) exists, but it’s not a safety net.
- Think strategically about fairness: The overriding objective isn’t just a procedural nicety — it’s the lens through which the court will assess your conduct. If your approach causes unnecessary cost or delay, expect consequences.
Final Thoughts
The High Court’s decision in Ward v Rai is a reminder that detailed assessment is not a free-for-all. It’s a structured process with clear rules — and those rules exist to ensure fairness, efficiency, and proportionality.
For those of us working in costs, this case reinforces a simple truth: if your Points of Dispute aren’t clear, specific, and timely, they may not be heard at all.
