Qualified One-Way Costs Shifting in Police Claims

Terminating the Solicitor/Client Retainer: A Costs Perspective from Evans v Acuity Law Ltd [2025] EWHC 1661 (SCCO)

In Evans v Acuity Law Ltd [2025] EWHC 1661 (SCCO), Costs Judge Nagalingam was asked to determine whether a solicitor’s decision to terminate a retainer just two days before a scheduled hearing was reasonable — and, crucially, whether that termination affected the solicitor’s entitlement to costs.

The case offers a timely and instructive reminder of the importance of clear communication, careful record-keeping, and managing client expectations — particularly when the solicitor/client relationship begins to break down.

The Background

In ALK & Anor v Chief Constable of Surrey Police [2025] EWHC 1964 (KB), the claimants brought a mixed claim that included a genuine personal injury component. Although the trial judge ordered them to pay 70% of the defendant’s costs, that decision was overturned on appeal. Mr Justice Bourne held that where a claim includes a genuine personal injury element, the default position under QOCS is costs neutrality — even if the claim ultimately fails.

By contrast, in Searson & Anor v Chief Constable of Nottingham Constabulary [2025] EWHC 1982 (KB), the claimants alleged false imprisonment and other torts. The second claimant also alleged personal injury but was awarded only nominal damages of £1.00. On appeal, Mr Justice Wall upheld the trial judge’s ruling that the first claimant had no QOCS protection and was liable for 100% of the costs ordered against him. The second claimant was granted partial protection and ordered to pay 50% of the costs.

The Leagal Issue

Both cases turned on the scope and limits of QOCS protection under CPR 44.13–44.17. The key question was whether the presence of a personal injury claim — and the nature of the damages awarded — was sufficient to trigger full QOCS protection.

In ALK, the court found that the personal injury claim was genuine and substantive, and that the mixed nature of the claim did not displace the presumption of costs neutrality. The appeal succeeded, and the claimants were shielded from adverse costs.

In Searson, however, the court took a more nuanced view. The personal injury claim was marginal and resulted in only nominal damages. The judge concluded that this did not justify full QOCS protection, particularly where the bulk of the claim related to non-personal injury causes of action.

The Appeal

On appeal in ALK, Mr Justice Bourne found that the personal injury claim was not only genuine but supported by medical evidence, which helped establish its substantive role in the litigation. The claimants — both police officers — had alleged false imprisonment and battery, and had submitted medical reports substantiating their injuries. This detail reinforced the court’s finding that the personal injury claim was not incidental or tactical, but central to the proceedings.

In Searson, the second claimant’s personal injury claim was awarded only nominal damages of £1.00, which the court interpreted as a sign that the injury was either trivial or not causally linked to the tortious conduct. This distinction — between a substantiated injury and a nominal award — was pivotal in determining the scope of QOCS protection.

The appeal in ALK succeeded, and the claimants were shielded from adverse costs. In Searson, the appeal failed, and the costs orders against both claimants were upheld.

Implications for Practice

  1. Genuine Personal Injury Matters
    Where a claim includes a substantive personal injury element, QOCS protection is likely to apply — even if the claim fails. The courts will look at the nature and seriousness of the injury, not just its presence on the pleadings.
  2. Nominal Damages May Undermine Protection
    A personal injury claim that results in nominal damages may not be enough to trigger full QOCS protection. Practitioners should be cautious about relying on minimal injury claims to shield clients from adverse costs.
  3. Mixed Claims Require Careful Framing
    Where personal injury is one of several heads of claim, the way the case is framed — and the relative weight of each element — can affect the costs outcome. Clear pleading and strategic emphasis are essential.
  4. Costs Risk Is Real in Police Litigation
    These cases highlight the costs risks inherent in actions against the police. Even where personal injury is alleged, claimants may face adverse costs orders if the injury is minor or the claim is unsuccessful.

Final Thoughts

ALK and Searson show that QOCS protection is not automatic in police claims — it depends on the substance of the personal injury claim and the overall structure of the case. For costs practitioners, the message is clear: assess the strength and scope of personal injury elements early, and advise clients accordingly.

These cases also reflect a broader judicial trend: courts are looking beyond the pleadings to assess the substance of personal injury claims in QOCS disputes. Where injury is central and supported, protection is likely; where it is peripheral or nominal, costs consequences may follow.

Where QOCS applies, it can be a powerful shield — but where it doesn’t, the financial consequences can be significant.

Stay Informed

If you found this article helpful, why not subscribe to our monthly Costs Law Newsletter? You’ll receive important updates, insights, and opinion in a concise, waffle-free email straight to your inbox.

Simply fill in the form below!

[wpcode id="4941"]

Recent Posts

  • All Posts
  • BarnsChapel News
  • Costs Law
  • Legal News

Categories

Subscribe to our Newsletter!

Let’s Talk!

Have a question about Costs Law that we haven’t answered, or want to have a chat about what we do and how we do it?

Use the contact details below to get in touch, or fill in our contact form and we will get right back to you.

+44 (0) 1244 256865

office@barnschapel.co.uk

© 2025 BarnsChapel Ltd. All Rights Reserved