Costs Orders Against Litigants in Person
In Cotham School v Bristol City Council & Anor (Re Consequential Matters) [2025] EWHC 1804 (Ch), HHJ Paul Matthews addressed the thorny issue of costs liability where one of the defendants — a litigant in person — had acted in the public interest but ultimately lost.
The judgment is a clear reaffirmation of the principle that litigants in person are not immune from adverse costs orders, and that acting in the public interest does not, in itself, shield a party from the usual consequences of litigation.
The Background
The case arose from a dispute over land used by Cotham School as playing fields.
The second defendant, a private individual acting without legal representation, had successfully applied to the first defendant, Bristol City Council, to register the land as a town green. Cotham School, which held a long lease over the land, brought proceedings to amend the commons register and succeeded.
Following judgment on the substantive claim, the court was asked to determine how costs should be apportioned between the two defendants.
Arguments on Costs
The second defendant argued that the first defendant — the local authority — should bear all or most of the claimant’s costs. She relied on two main points:
- Her status as a litigant in person; and
- Her role in acting in the public interest.
The claimant, however, submitted that the second defendant had led the defence to the claim and should therefore bear the majority of the costs — proposing a 90/10 split in her disfavour.
The Judgment
HHJ Matthews rejected the suggestion that being a litigant in person or acting in the public interest should insulate a party from costs liability. He held that the normal rules applied, and that the second defendant’s role in leading the defence was a significant factor.
Accordingly, the court ordered:
- The first defendant (Bristol City Council) to pay 10% of the claimant’s costs;
- The second defendant to pay 90% of the claimant’s costs.
The judge also ordered a payment on account of costs, set at 40% of the claimant’s approved budget, apportioned between the defendants in line with the above percentages.
Key Takeaways for Practitioners
- Litigants in person are not exempt from costs: The court reaffirmed that self-representation does not alter the application of the general rule that the unsuccessful party pays the successful party’s costs.
- Public interest is not a shield: While acting in the public interest may be a relevant factor in some cases, it does not override the fundamental principle that costs follow the event.
- Leading the defence carries consequences: Where a party — represented or not — takes the lead in defending a claim, they may be held primarily responsible for the costs if the defence fails.
- Payments on account remain available: Even in cases involving litigants in person, the court may order interim payments on account of costs, particularly where a costs management order has been made.
Final Thoughts
Cotham School v Bristol City Council & Anor is a reminder that costs liability is grounded in responsibility, not representation. The court’s approach was pragmatic and principled: litigants in person are entitled to access the courts, but they are also subject to the same risks as any other party.
For costs lawyers and litigators, the case reinforces the importance of assessing not just the outcome of a case, but the conduct and role of each party in shaping its course. Public interest arguments may carry moral weight — but they do not displace the rules of costs.
Stay Informed
If you found this article helpful, why not subscribe to our monthly Costs Law Newsletter? You’ll receive important updates, insights, and opinion in a concise, waffle-free email straight to your inbox.
Simply fill in the form below!
